My personal views on wildlife conservation and the work of the Heart of the Levels Group of the Somerset Wildlife Trust
Search This Blog
Thursday, September 30, 2021
Climate Change and Adaption! Local action
Wednesday, September 29, 2021
New thinking on how to control development -Biodiversity Net Gain
Read about all this on Natural EnglandBlog at:
naturalenglandblog.gov.uk
************************************************************************
Comment posted by Professor Ian Rotherham posted on
Sunday, September 19, 2021
Silent Earth by Dave Goulson
I'm half way through my birthday book called Silent Earth written by Dave Goulson and it made me think immediately of Rachel Carson and her book Silent Spring which had made a big impression on me a few years ago!
He introduces the book with a dramatic sub title "Averting the Insect Apocalypse "
Chapter 2 starts with a quote from EO Wilson American Biologist "If all mankind were to disappear the world would regenerate back to the rich state that existed 10,000 years ago. If insects were to vanish the environment would collapse into chaos"
Chapter 6 quotes Wilson again " Destroying rainforest for economic gain is like burning a Renaissance painting to cook a meal "
A big problem is the idea that catastrophic losses can be offset - which often they cannot. Whilst there are great opportunities to get developers and business to reinvest in biodiversity this should not be an excuse for irreparable damage. Landscape heritage is also not replaceable or capable of being 'offset' - so ancient woods, ancient hedges, veteran trees, traditional unimproved grasslands etc cannot be compensated for. The other real worry with this is the incentive for consultants to offer (for a good-sized fee) offset solutions which are essentially pie-in-the-sky and incapable of realistic delivery and not transparent in terms of their long-term outcomes. This appeals to developers, to politicians, and to planning inspectors since it justifies damaging developments but with a clear conscience - greenwash. We need to engage business and others in genuine commitment to sustainable ecological and heritage solutions. Finally, losses at a particular locale cannot be genuinely offset by actions displaced to another site - ecological systems & local communities simply do not operate in that way. We require more genuinely visionary and pragmatic solutions.
Comments welcome!